The problem of assessing effective neuroprotection in experimental cerebral ischemia
Introduction
Stroke or cerebral ischemia is a leading cause of death and permanent disability for which there is currently no effective treatment. New drug therapies and other interventions have emerged that may limit this type of brain injury (Koroshetz and Moskowitz, 1996). However, these therapies are typically evaluated in animal stroke models simply by counting the remaining number of healthy cells or calculating infarct volumes 1–7 days after the ischemic episode. Recent research suggests that some treatments may only delay cell death, whereas others leave cells in a functionally abnormal state. In this review we examine the pitfalls associated with current methods of gauging neuroprotective efficacy in both global and focal models of ischemia. An alternative evaluative approach is put forth that incorporates behavioural, neurophysiological and histological indices of neuroprotection.
Section snippets
The issue of postponed cell death
Histological endpoints (i.e. cell counts) determined up to 7 days after ischemia are customarily used to assess the efficacy of potential therapeutic interventions. A major problem with this strategy is that a number of drugs and other treatments appear to only postpone cell death (Morse and Davis, 1990; Li and Buchan, 1995; Nurse and Corbett, 1996; Dietrich et al., 1993; Colbourne and Corbett, 1994; Valtysson et al., 1994; Corbett and Crooks, 1997). Thus, cells that appear preserved by some
Histological assessment
The first concern with histological assessment is: what to count and what to measure? It is well known that CA1 neurons are highly susceptible to global ischemic injury and their laminar distribution and large size make them relatively easy to quantify. However, other neuronal populations (e.g. CA2 and hilar neurons) are equally, if not more sensitive, to global ischemia (Hsu and Buzsaki, 1993; Matsuyama et al., 1993; Akai and Yanagihara, 1993). Yet neuronal loss within these regions is rarely
Neuropathology
In general, the pattern of neuronal injury in gerbil and rat models of global ischemia is very similar (Pulsinelli et al., 1982; Kirino and Sano, 1984; Smith et al., 1984; Crain et al., 1988) with CA1, CA2, hilar, dorsolateral caudate and cortical neurons (in middle layers) being the most vulnerable. Due to its incomplete circle of Willis, it is easy to produce near total forebrain ischemia in the gerbil by occluding the carotid arteries for either 3 or 5 min. The ensuing loss of CA1 neurons,
Neuropathology
Most models of focal ischemia involve permanent or temporary occlusion of the MCA (Tamura et al., 1981; Buchan et al., 1992; Longa et al., 1989) that supplies the lateral surface of the cerebral cortex and a limited number of subcortical structures, most notably the caudate nucleus (Scremin, 1995). These cortical and striatal areas are known to be involved in the processing and integration of sensory-motor information (Whishaw et al., 1986; Andersen et al., 1991) and thus most investigators
Electrophysiology
The previous sections discussed the importance of using behavioural tests in conjunction with a histological evaluation following global and focal ischemia. However, in most behavioural tests there is often considerable recovery following ischemia. In many cases, deficits in behavioural tasks are only observed within the first few weeks after the insult (Markgraf et al., 1992; Andersen et al., 1991; Corbett et al., 1992). Recent studies have provided evidence that neuronal death can continue
Conclusions
It should be clear from the foregoing discussion of global and focal ischemic studies that assessing neuroprotection solely on the basis of conventional histological procedures (e.g. Nissl stains) is not adequate. Examples were presented where different treatments (hypothermia, ischemic preconditioning and neuroprotective drugs) appeared to convey neuroprotection when histological endpoints were used but considerably less efficacy was found with functional endpoints. To some extent these
Acknowledgements
This work was supported by grants from the Medical Research Council of Canada, the Heart and Stroke Foundation of Newfoundland and Labrador and the Astra Canadian Neuroscience Network awarded to DC. The authors would like to thank Jennifer Dowden and Paul Dooley for helpful comments on this manuscript.
References (164)
- et al.
Identity of the dorsal hippocampal region most vulnerable to cerebral ischemia
Brain Res.
(1993) - et al.
Neurological correlates of unilateral and bilateral strokes of the middle cerebral artery in the rat
Physiol. Behav.
(1991) - et al.
Absence of electrographic seizures after transient forebrain ischemia in the Mongolian gerbil
Brain Res.
(1989) - et al.
Locomotor activity in the ischemic gerbil
Brain Res.
(1993) - et al.
Importance of preoperative training and maze difficulty in task performance following hippocampal damage in the gerbil
Brain Res. Bull.
(1997) - et al.
Blockade of the AMPA receptor prevents CA1 hippocampal severe but transient forebrain ischemia in adult rats
Neurosci. Lett.
(1991) - et al.
Post-ischemic moderate hypothermia inhibits CA1 hippocampal ischemic neuronal injury
Neurosci. Lett.
(1989) - et al.
An unanesthetized-gerbil model of cerebral ischemia-induced behavioral changes
J. Pharmacol. Methods
(1985) - et al.
Adenylate cyclase activity and motor behavior following cerebral ischemia in the unanesthetized gerbil
Life Sci.
(1985) - et al.
Ischemic tolerance can be induced repeatedly in the gerbil hippocampal neurons
Neurosci. Lett.
(1994)
Delayed and prolonged post-ischemic hypothermia is neuroprotective in the gerbil
Brain Res.
MK-801 reduces cerebral ischemic injury by inducing hypothermia
Brain Res.
Ischemic preconditioning: a long term survival study using behavioural and histological endpoints
Brain Res.
Persistent degenerative state of non-pyramidal neurons in the CA1 region of the gerbil hippocampus following transient forebrain ischemia
Neurosci.
In vivo intracellular demonstration of an ischemia-induced postsynaptic potential from CA1 pyramidal neurons in rat hippocampus
Neurosci.
Protection of CA1 cell function by MK-801 following ischemia in the gerbil
Neurosci. Lett.
Some effects of hippocampal lesions on the behavior of mongolian gerbils
Physiol. Behav.
The effects of forebrain ischaemia on spatial learning
Behav. Brain Res.
Anoxic LTP sheds light on the multiple facets of NMDA receptors
Trends Neurosci.
Functional and morphological changes induced by transient in vivo ischemia
Exper. Neurol.
Animal models of acute ischemic stroke: can they predict clinically successful neuroprotective drugs?
Trends Pharmacol. Sci.
Sensory-motor deficit and recovery from thrombotic infarction of the vibrissal barrel-field cortex
Brain Res.
Effects of transient cerebral ischemia in gerbils on working memory performance in the delayed nonmatching to position task using a T-maze
Japan J. Pharmacol.
Pentobarbital protects against CA1 pyramidal cell death but not dysfunction of hippocampal cholinergic neurons following transient ischemia
Brain Res.
Spatial learning is affected by transient occlusion of common carotid arteries (2VO): comparison of behavioural and histopathological changes after 2VO and four-vessel-occlusion in rats
Neurosci. Lett.
Protection against post-ischemic behavioral pathology by the α-amino-3-hydroxy-5-methyl-4-isoxazolepropionic acid (AMPA) antagonist 2,3-dihydoxy-6-nitro-7-sulfamoyl-benzo(f) quinoxaline (NBQX) in the gerbil
Neurosci. Lett.
Temporal profile of the effects of pretreatment with brief cerebral ischemia on the neuronal damage following secondary ischemic insult in the gerbil: cumulative damage and protective effects
Brain Res.
Ischemia-induced irreversible deficit of memory function in gerbils
Brain Res.
Delayed neuronal death in the gerbil hippocampus following ischemia
Brain Res.
Emerging treatments for stroke in humans
Trends in Pharmacol. Sci.
Locomotor hyperactivity and hippocampal CA1 injury after transient forebrain ischemia of gerbils
Neurosci. Lett.
Therapeutic window of halothane anesthesia for reversal of delayed neuronal injury in gerbils: relationship to postischemic motor hyperactivity
Brain Res.
Transient ischemia attenuates neuronal afterdischarges induced in the absence of synaptic transmission
Brain Res.
Effects of clomethiazole on radial-arm maze performance following global forebrain ischemia in gerbils
Brain Res.
Protection of rat hippocampus against ischemic neuronal damage by pretreatment with sublethal ischemia
Brain Res.
An analysis of various environmental and specific sensory stimuli on the seizure activity of the Mongolian gerbil
Epilepsy Res.
Assessment of functional impairment following permanent middle cerebral artery occlusion in a non-human primate species
Neurodegeneration
The use of locomotor activity as a behavioral screen for neuronal damage following transient forebrain ischemia in gerbils
Neurosci. Lett.
Transient forebrain ischemia of three-minute duration consistently induces severe neuronal damage in field CA1 of the hippocampus in the normothermic gerbil
Neurosci. Lett.
A golgi study of cell types in the hilar region of the hippocampus in the rat
J. Comp. Neurol.
An alternative method for the quantitation of neuronal damage after experimental middle cerebral artery occlusion in rats: Analysis of behavioral deficit
J. Cereb. Blood Flow Metab.
Electrophysiological changes in substantia nigra after striatal infarction
Neuroreport
Neurobehavioral deficit due to ischemic brain damage limited to half of the CA1 sector of the hippocampus
J. Neurosci.
Cerebral ischemia: Are the memory deficits associated with hippocampal cell loss
Hippocampus
Histological, biochemical and behavioral evidence for the neuroprotective action of chlormethiazole following prolonged carotid artery occlusion
Neurodegeneration
An autoradiograhic examination of corticocortical amd subcortical projections of the mediodorsal-projection (Prefrontal) in the rat
J. Comp. Neurol.
Selective vulnerability of hippocampus and disturbances of memory storage after mild unilateral ischemia of gerbil brain
Stroke
Hypothermia but not the N-Methyl-D-Aspartate antagonist, MK-801 attenuates neuronal damage in gerbils subjected to transient global ischemia
J. Neurosci.
A new model of temporary focal neocortical ischemia in the rat
Stroke
Cited by (250)
Intermittent fasting along with hydroalcoholic extract of Centella-asiatica ameliorates sub-acute hypoxia-induced ischemic stroke in adult zebrafish
2024, Comparative Biochemistry and Physiology Part - C: Toxicology and PharmacologyDHA-enriched formulations as a promising strategy for the treatment of hypoxic/ischemic brain injury
2019, Omega Fatty Acids in Brain and Neurological HealthEthyl-acetate fraction of Trichilia catigua restores long-term retrograde memory and reduces oxidative stress and inflammation after global cerebral ischemia in rats
2018, Behavioural Brain ResearchCitation Excerpt :This suggests that histological protection is not necessarily required for functional recovery. The most important end-point for assessing the neuroprotective potential of drugs should be functional recovery, despite the obvious importance of preserving as many neurons as possible after an ischemic insult [20]. Our behavioral vs. histological data can be reconciled by considering that the “dysfunction of complex behaviors and recovery may reflect alterations at the subcellular, synaptic or electrophysiological levels, or even of widespread morphological changes that cannot be quantified by a simple cell count in a restricted region of a given structure” [5].